Shirley Williams: Europe has a duty to Gaza (via The Guardian)

Baroness Williams
Baroness Williams of Crosby

Civilian suffering shocked the public in the first world war, but we have become numb to it

The tragedy of the centenary we commemorate this week is that it falls as some of the most brutal and merciless wars of those same hundred years are raging. What characterises contemporary wars above all – in Syria, Gaza, Iraq, Ukraine, the Democratic Republic of the Congo and the Central African Republic – is that the main victims are civilians, many of them utterly innocent children. Furthermore their deaths and injuries cannot be dismissed as unintended consequences of war. Some are deliberate.

Attacks on Belgian and French civilians, including children, by Germany’s invading army in August 1914 shocked the public and politicians in Britain and elsewhere into intervening, and many individual men into enlisting – so much so that conscription in Britain was not introduced until 1916. Among those appalled by the attacks on civilians was my mother, Vera Brittain, who was to become the author of Testament of Youth, a remarkable memoir of the war. Her childhood dream had been to go to Oxford University and become a writer. But the suffering of civilians and the mounting toll of soldiers compelled her to abandon that dream and sign on as a volunteer nurse in military hospitals in England, Malta and France.

Reports of civilian and soldier deaths in 1914 were carried in Britain by local as well as national newspapers. But today’s television images of dead babies, terrified children, destroyed homes in ruined streets, while evoking outrage, also have a numbing effect: so much horror, so much violence that the traditional distinctions between civilians and soldiers, originating in Saint Thomas Aquinas’s concept of a “just war” seem irrelevant.

Full article here



One thought on “Shirley Williams: Europe has a duty to Gaza (via The Guardian)”

  1. Edmond Spriet (aged 41) died as a civilian victim on 28 May 1918, levaing behind his widowed wife and a family of 5.
    He was working right behind the line in the ‘deserted village of Leke’ (Dixmude sector, Flanders front) as a day labourer conscripted by the German forces when it happened. His team were shelled with ‘friendly’ fire coming from an English plane, and he bled to death on the doorstep of his little workman’s house.
    My father, the youngest member of the family, never knew his dad, being barely three months old when it happened.
    Edmond’s widow, my godmother, survived her husband by 55 years. Ten years after his death, in 1928, she was still signing my dad’s school results using her dead husband’s name.
    Edmond S. was the granddad that I never had.

    Let everyone refuse to consider the ‘collateral damage’ that wars inflict on people as an evidence. Thank you so much, Mrs Williams.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s